ClaimWhose voiceWhere it stands
The Human Cell Atlas's first draft reference, from single-cell data on dissociated cells, is approaching completion.
Company-reported
Her own account of the consortium's progress, with no date or list of tissues; not checked here against a consortium release.
The v1.0 blood reference holds over 10,000 samples from North America, Latin America, Europe and Asia.
Company-reported
She hedges it herself ('I think over 10,000'); the figure was not checked on the data portal.
Atrial fibrillation risk variants act in myocardial sleeve cells of the pulmonary vein, in the opposite direction from bulk data.
Company-reported
She calls it her group's recent work; the paper was not read here.
Cell atlas data predicts which targets and drugs pass Phase I, II and III.
Company-reported
She cites her own group's preprint (medRxiv, April 2024). Its abstract says cell-type specificity robustly predicts progress from Phase I to II and that its link to approval is 'less clear', narrower than the interview; and it is retrospective.
Going from AI prediction to the lab is an iteration across kinds of experiment, not one prediction and one test.
Guest's judgment
Her view of how the work goes, with no worked example in figures.
Robotised perturbation data is systematic, disease data is not, and it needs careful integration to say what happens in the body.
Guest's judgment
Her judgment.
The atlas's effect on drug development has not yet been quantified, because drug development lags.
Not yet closed
She says herself it is the question she thinks about, and 'we're only now starting to see' it.